The PP and Vox remove from the Coast Law the article that intended to curb the saturation of the coastline
The two parties eliminate in parliamentary committee the principles that obligated to take into account the carrying capacity of the coast, the urban pressure and the protection of the ecosystems
-
CAT -
CAST
PalmaThe PP and Vox agreed this Wednesday, during the presentation of the Coastal Law in the Balearic Parliament, to completely delete the article that established the principles to avoid the saturation of the coastline and promote its sustainable management. It is article 6, dedicated to the comprehensive management of the coast, which set criteria to guide the decisions of the administrations and limit certain projects or activities that could compromise the conservation of these spaces. The suppression affects issues such as the carrying capacity of the beaches, urban pressure, coastal regression, the prevention of natural risks, and the protection of Posidonia.
The article had a general character, but precisely for that reason it was relevant according to sources consulted by ARA Balears. It established the principles that were to guide the application of the law and that could serve as a foundation to justify restrictions on certain activities or projects. It did not introduce automatic prohibitions, but it provided environmental and territorial criteria that the administrations had to take into consideration when ordering and managing the coastline.
Its disappearance is especially significant because the regulation promoted by the Government of Marga Prohens is presented as a law for the planning, protection, and comprehensive management of the coastline. In fact, when the Governing Council approved the project last June, the Executive argued that it would allow for strengthening the protection of coastal ecosystems and ensuring sustainable management of the beaches and the uses of the coast. Now, the agreement between the PP and Vox eliminates one of the articles that most explicitly formulated these objectives.
The suppression is part of the negotiations between the two parties to approve a regulation that has sparked controversy since the beginning of its drafting. Vox has repeatedly expressed its rejection of policies linked to the sustainable development agenda, a position that contrasts with the environmental criteria that the deleted article included.
Avoiding saturation and the accumulation of constructions
The content of article 6 allows one to understand the scope of the decision. The first section established that the comprehensive management of the coastline had to jointly take into account hydrological, geomorphological, climatic, ecological, socioeconomic, and cultural systems. The purpose was not to exceed the carrying and hosting capacity of the coast and to prevent the negative effects of natural disasters and “uncontrolled saturation”.
It also incorporated an express reference to the preservation and restoration of Posidonia meadows, one of the essential ecosystems for the conservation of the Balearic coastline. Another of the eliminated principles referred to the protection of the coast against sea regression, caused by both natural and human factors, with the aim of minimizing its effects on ecosystems and economic activities.
But one of the points of greatest territorial significance was the one that proposed guaranteeing a balanced planning of the land strip of the coastline, avoiding, as far as possible, the accumulation of construction volumes and densities. This principle could serve as a reference to assess the impact of new buildings or economic activities in areas that already suffer from high human pressure.
The article also established the need to develop strategies and land-use plans that took into account environmental and socioeconomic impacts, in addition to preventively assessing the risks associated with infrastructure and human activities. Finally, it incorporated the obligation to prevent damage to the coastal environment and to restore it when necessary.
The disappearance of this set of principles does not mean that the protections established by other state, regional, or European laws are automatically rendered ineffective, but it does eliminate from the Balearic bill an express formulation of the general criteria that were to condition the management of the coastline.
A law marked by the protection of the shearwaters
The modification has a special dimension if the political background of the Coastal Law is taken into account. One of the main motivations of the Prohens Executive has been to seek formulas to protect certain constructions and activities existing on the coast, some of which are in a complicated legal situation because they occupy the maritime-terrestrial public domain.
As explained by ARA Balears in different reports, the regulation aims to provide coverage for traditional coastal constructions, such as 'escars' (boat slips) and seaside huts, but the debate also affects beach bars, restaurants, and other facilities located in especially protected areas. One of the avenues the Government has explored is the recognition of the heritage, cultural, or ethnological value of certain constructions. The objective is to have new instruments to defend their conservation, even in cases where the state coastal regulations pose difficulties for maintaining them.
This approach has generated questions about to what extent heritage recognition might end up benefiting commercial activities that do not have the necessary authorizations or that occupy public domain spaces. The controversy is especially significant in the case of seafront catering establishments, because the heritage protection of a construction and the right to conduct an economic activity there are legally distinct issues.
The State retains jurisdiction over the public domain
The Balearic Government assumed new management and planning functions for the coastline in July 2023, but this transfer did not entail the cession of the ownership of the maritime-terrestrial public domain, which remains state-owned.
Therefore, a declaration of heritage value approved by the regional administration does not, by itself, guarantee that a structure can continue to occupy this public domain if it violates state legislation. Basic coastal regulations and the powers retained by the State continue to condition authorizations, concessions, and the possibility of maintaining certain facilities. This jurisdictional conflict has already appeared in other autonomous communities. ARA Balears has reported on the Valencian precedent, where the State has appealed to the Constitutional Court regarding regulations with mechanisms for the protection of coastal structures similar to those intended to be promoted in the Islands.
The desire to preserve traditional elements of the coastal landscape therefore coexists with a legal debate over the limits of regional powers and another of an environmental nature: which uses can be maintained on the coast and under what conditions.
The warnings from environmentalists
Concern regarding the lack of environmental safeguards has been present throughout the legislative process. Organizations such as GOB and the Marilles Foundation have questioned various aspects of the proposal and warned of the need to prevent the new regulations from facilitating greater occupation of the coast.
Among the issues raised is the need to establish carrying capacity criteria, limit activities in saturated areas, and ensure that ecosystem conservation is an effective priority in administrative decisions. Precisely, the article that the PP and Vox have suppressed included some of these principles, albeit with a general formulation that would have required concrete instruments to apply them.
The draft law also regulates the distribution of powers between the Government, the island councils, and the municipalities, the classification of beaches according to their degree of protection, economic activities, and seasonal services, in addition to certain navigation limitations. On November 10th, the PP and Vox already prevented the amendment to the entirety presented by the PSIB from prospering, which questioned the direction of the project and demanded that it be returned to the Government.
The agreement reached now in committee once again highlights the tensions between the environmental objectives that the Government announced when presenting the law and the modifications introduced during the parliamentary processing. The final legal significance of the suppression will depend on the content of the rest of the articles and how the rule remains when approved. But the change has a clear meaning: the future Balearic Islands Coastal Law loses the article that expressly established the need to respect the carrying capacity of the coastline, avoid its saturation, and limit the impacts of human activities on the coast.