Why have the PP and Vox declared war on a ghost in the Balearic Islands?

4 min
Marga Prohens this Friday at the Consolat
17/11/2026 - 10:36 h
Professor at the UIB

It has been a week of ultra-right overdose, with the honorable exception of the general strike on November 11th. On Monday, Santiago Abascal sat on the set of La Revuelta on public television, in a tense interview that the far-right has already turned into electoral ammunition and in which he gave us a preview of his particular idea of freedom of expression, guaranteed with a hand-picked audience… What will happen, if they govern, to those of us who do not want to applaud them? But while the country was arguing about Broncano, the next day, the Parliament of the Balearic Islands did something much more serious: approving, with the votes of Vox and the PP, a proposal for an organic law to ban the burqa and the niqab in public spaces, which will now be sent to Congress.

I start with the evidence: where are the burqas in Mallorca? Nobody has seen one queuing at the Inca health center or waiting for the bus in Manacor. The Maghrebian women who live in our towns and neighborhoods, when they cover themselves, wear a scarf, the hijab, which does not hide the face. And if we ever see one walking around Palma, it is more likely that she has stepped off a luxury yacht from the Emirates or Saudi Arabia than from a boat. We are legislating, therefore, against a ghost. But not just any ghost: a useful ghost.

Because the law was not written for the women it claims to liberate, but for the audience expected to applaud it, like on Broncano's show with Abascal. One only needs to read its statement of motives: it speaks of Christian and Greco-Roman civilization, of “massive arrival of immigrants” and of an “unacceptable increase” of the foreign population. It states that “it is not a matter of religious feelings”, yet it only prohibits two garments associated with a single religion. The dignity of women is the wrapping; the content is to single out specific neighbors. It would be laughable, if it were not saddening, that the party which denies sexist violence, which walks out of moments of silence for murdered women, and which wants to put an end to equality policies, now presents itself as a defender of Muslim women. Their feminism begins and ends exactly where their xenophobia begins.

And they do so by precisely punishing those they claim to protect: if a woman wears the niqab because it is imposed on her, she is the one who is fined. If she reoffends, the infraction becomes serious, with penalties of up to 30,000 euros. And if she is a foreigner, the reform of the Immigration Law opens the door to expulsion. First, the violence of the husband or the father; then, that of the State. A double condemnation. And the predictable effect is that these women, if they exist, will not set foot on the street, in school, or in the health center again, the only spaces where someone could help them.

The criminal part does not withstand a careful reading either. Forcing someone to dress in a certain way is already a crime: it is called coercion and it is in article 172 of the Penal Code. Vox fits its new class within the article on harassment, and writes it with such care that it repeats “precautionary measure” three times. They didn't even proofread it. It is not new either: Congress already rejected this same text, with the same title, on February 17th, by 177 votes to 170. And it invokes the ruling of the European Court of Human Rights in the S.A.S. against France case, but omits that that same ruling ruled out that equality between men and women or security could justify a general ban.

The Arabist Dolors Bramon, who has dedicated half her life to studying women in Islam and who is not at all complacent about the veil, has explained it many times: the burqa does not come from the Quran, it is likely older than Islam, and turning it into a religious symbol is confusing belief with tradition. And she also warns us that prohibitions do not liberate anyone: they only radicalize positions.

But my fear is more immediate… Because laws also educate, and this one teaches that the clothing of a minority is a threat to public order. Whoever hears the message will not distinguish between a niqab and a headscarf. It would not surprise me if, with the excuse of this perverse rule, any of these days, some exalted follower of the ultra-right believes themselves authorized to pull the headscarf off a Moroccan girl at the exit of high school. With this law, there will not be fewer burqas, because there are none: there will be more fear, and it will be easier to point fingers.

It is not an isolated incident. The same plenary session approved requesting the suspension of the Arabic language and Moroccan culture program in schools. This is not feminism, it is an agenda. And Marga Prohens' PP, which boasts of moderation, voted for it and applauded it, as if the coexistence in these Islands were worth less than the pact with Vox.

Evil does not always scream. Sometimes it is voted for on a Tuesday, between two motions, with a tie neatly tied and a cross of Christ shining brightly on the chest. The far right does not want to solve problems: it needs them. And when it cannot find any, it invents them.

stats