Vulture funds will not be able to evict Margalida, sick with cancer and a resident of Pere Garau for 60 years
A court in Palma has dismissed the lawsuit of two investment funds to terminate the old-rent lease agreement of the woman, who wanted to return to her home after going through the hospital
-
CAT -
CAST -
DE
PalmaA Palma court has rejected the eviction of Margalida, an 87-year-old woman, cancer patient, and resident of the Pere Garau neighborhood, where she has lived for more than six decades. The ruling completely dismisses the lawsuit filed by two investment funds, which sought to terminate the woman's old-rent lease agreement due to several delays in the payment of monthly installments.
The judicial resolution, which was made public by her lawyer, Aina Díaz, considers that in this case there are exceptional personal and care circumstances that do not justify the termination of the contract. The judge also takes into account the absence of significant prejudice to the property, the long duration of the rental relationship without significant history of non-compliance, and the fact that the outstanding amounts had been paid in full before the resolution of the dispute. Furthermore, it orders the investment funds to pay the legal costs.
“The court completely dismisses the lawsuit against Margalida. And it orders the funds that tried to terminate the old-rent contract and evict an 87-year-old woman, a cancer patient, to pay the costs,” Díaz wrote on the social network X.
The judge considers that the delays in payments did not constitute a sufficient breach to frustrate the economic purpose of the contract nor to justify its termination. The ruling is based on the most recent doctrine of the Supreme Court and concludes that the facts are framed within an exceptional situation.
A contract signed in 1963
Margalida's history with this home goes back more than 60 years. The lease agreement was signed in 1963 and, after her husband's death in 2007, the woman took over the ownership in 2008. During the following years, as explained by her lawyer, there were no problems with the property owners. Margalida, who is from Mallorca, paid just over 12 euros a month under the old rent contract.
The situation changed in 2021, when an investment company acquired almost the entire property. According to the defense's version, the new owners did not inform the tenants of the change of ownership until a year later. The communication, moreover, would have been difficult for Margalida to understand, who at that time was 83 years old and suffering from breast cancer.
In 2023 she had surgery for the cancer and, after a hospital stay to recover from a mastectomy, she spent a few months at her only son's home. When she returned to her residence, she found a burofax demanding the payment of a year's rent that, according to the property, was outstanding. The amount totaled about 150 euros.
The problem, according to the lawyer's account, had arisen from the change of property ownership, which had also led to a change in the bank account where the monthly payment had to be deposited. Margalida had not managed to understand why the receipts had not been collected. She went to a bank branch so that they would help her make the payment and she managed to pay the outstanding amounts, but she did not manage to set up a direct debit for the monthly payments to avoid the situation repeating itself.
She wanted to return to her home, in her usual neighborhood
A few months later, Margalida suffered a fall that caused her to fracture three vertebrae. After another hospital stay, she returned to live temporarily with her son, who contacted the owners to inform them that, from that moment on, he would be in charge of matters related to his mother's home.
According to what Díaz explained, the property representatives took advantage of this contact to ask him for the keys to the apartment under the excuse of carrying out renovations. When they assumed the woman would not return, the son clarified to them that his mother wanted to resume her life at the home in Pere Garau. “She wanted to die in her own home, in her neighborhood, where she feels safe and knows everyone,” explained the lawyer who relayed this to them.
The lawyer also reported that, after this conversation, the owners began taking actions that made Margalida's situation even more difficult. According to her account, they removed the intercom and her name from the mailbox, and someone impersonated her identity to cancel the water meter service.
When the son asked for explanations, the property owners informed him that the woman was once again a year behind on her rent. He reproached them for not having notified him sooner, especially since they had been in contact for months. The owners sent him a document with the claimed amounts, but, still according to the defense, they did not provide him with the bank account where he was supposed to make the payment, despite his having requested it.
A lawsuit for rent delays
At the beginning of 2025, Margalida received an extrajudicial mediation request in which she was warned that, if she did not pay the claimed amounts, she would be sued within one month. The eviction lawsuit was filed in May of that same year. The investment funds argued that the delays in payments justified the termination of the contract.
The woman's lawyer has maintained that the company knew about the illness Margalida was suffering from and that it let the debt accumulate month after month before filing the lawsuit. Finally, the court has considered that the elderly woman's personal circumstances, the nature of the delays, and the payment of the outstanding amounts did not justify a measure as serious as terminating the rental contract.
Margalida will be able to continue in the home in Pere Garau where she has lived for more than 60 years.