The GOB takes the transfer of waste from Ibiza to the courts: "The concept of a pilot project is a fraud"
Environmentalists and residents point out numerous alleged breaches of the regulations
-
CAT -
CAST -
DE
PalmaThe GOB pointed out this Friday numerous alleged legislative breaches in the waste transfer file in Ibiza. Representatives of the environmental organization have admitted that they were surprised by the amount of alleged irregularities that, according to them, their lawyers have detected. Among them, a possible false justification of the contract as a pilot project: “The concept of a pilot project must allow for stopping, and it does not do so,” said GOB spokesperson Aina Llauger. Together with the neighborhood associations of Son Sardina and La Garriga, the entity has filed a contentious-administrative appeal against the contract and have demanded the immediate suspension of the file.
As explained in a press conference, the spokespersons for the three entities criticize that the administration is presenting the transfer as a pilot project, but it is not clear that there are real mechanisms to stop it if the results are not satisfactory. "The concept of a pilot project is a fraud," added the spokesperson for the residents of La Garriga, Joan Mateos. The plaintiffs also question that the administration could hide behind possible compensation to the awarded company to maintain the transfer. Furthermore, they believe that the administration may have violated public procurement regulations because the contract has not been divided into lots, despite including different services that could have been tendered separately. Mateos highlighted that a global contract has been awarded to a company that "only executes 4% of the specific work," while the rest corresponds to the transport of waste in trucks. Specifically, the Council of Ibiza and the Council of Mallorca awarded a contract to the joint venture UTE GIREF for an estimated value of 22 million euros. They also denounce the violation of the principle of free concurrence and competition, because the contract has been awarded to a single company, without effective competition.
According to the plaintiffs, the contract would have also breached European regulations, because it was not properly communicated or advertised. In this regard, they propose requesting a preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). Furthermore, they point out that the administration would have created the conditions for only one company to be the successful bidder. In the same vein, they denounce that the regulations were modified to facilitate the transfer of waste when administrative procedures had already begun through the omnibus law, with a sense of urgency that was not justified, because the treatment plant in Ca na Putxa (Ibiza) does not reach the end of its useful life until 2029. In addition, they consider that the legislative modification approved by the Balearic Government invades powers regulated by state public procurement regulations, and they demand that the court raise a question of unconstitutionality in this regard. Finally, they warn of a possible violation of the waste management hierarchy and the proximity principle due to the fact of transporting them from Ibiza to Mallorca instead of seeking a way to process the waste in Ibiza.
The Government is not considering changes: “It’s not going that badly”
Asked about the matter in the press conference following the Government Council, the first vice president, Antoni Costa, expressed “respect” for the appeal. “The Government and the Council also have every right to ensure that this file is processed through the ordinary channel and nothing more,” he said. “The transport of waste from Ibiza has not caused anything that it was said it would cause,” he explained. “At first it appeared in the media, but afterwards it did not: it must not be going so badly, I would say,” he affirmed.